CCTV New Laws- Making a nation of spies

At the risk of stating the obvious, CCTV in the UK is everywhere. With ANPR in the UK now live, “intelligent” CCTV being developed, some of which allows profiling of people. It is well reported that the UK is now the most watched country on earth, with a report 4.2 million cameras in the U (though this figure is probably not accurate )

Despite this, its still not enough for the government, and they are creating new laws (Closed Circuit Television (Monitoring and Promotion) Bill 2007-08) to ensure all of the CCTV cameras that councils have become available to police and central government.

The bill states that it will “impose a duty on public bodies to co-operate with the police and specified local authorities on the use of closed circuit television; to require certain users of CCTV to provide specified information to the police; to require insurance providers to promote the use of CCTV systems; and for connected purposes.”

This means that users of CCTV could, effectively, be called on to assist in the spying on the UK public.

The sponsor of the bill is Ann McKechinAnn McKechin, pictured inset. Ann, a labour MP is not exactly a classic liberal. She voted strongly for ID cards, very strongly for anti-terrorism laws, and against an investigation into the Iraq war.

 

 

 

 

 

Tags: ,

ANPR Data Retention set to be 5 Years

ANPR Data Retention Period is set to be 5 years, which is signifcantly longer than any other UK legislation, which relates to the storage of data for anti-terrorism purposes, or the even the EU legislation that recommends 2 years.

So why five years? Are terrorists using the same cars for 5 years? As they will normally clone or steal a car it seems unlikely.  Is it because terrorists plans take 5 years, possibly, but that’s a lot of data to trawl through to try and find a clumsy terrorist 5 years ago.

Or is it because the government would build a complete picture of our traveling habits, over a sustained period?

Answers on a postcard.

Posted in ANPR. No Comments »

Does CCTV Work (Scotland)

In 1993 the Scottish governemtn conducted a review of the investigation of CCTV, and its ability to  reduce crime in a given area: Airdrie, just east of Glasgow.

The key findings are the results were

 

# 21% fewer crimes and offences were recorded in the 24 months after installation of CCTV in Airdrie town centre compared to the 24 months prior to the introduction of CCTV. (This figure, and those given below, have been adjusted to remove the effects of seasonality and underlying trends).
# Crimes of dishonesty, which include housebreaking, shoplifting and theft of and from motor vehicles, saw the largest percentage reduction of 48% in the 24 months after CCTV.
# Crimes of fireraising and vandalism fell by 19% following the installation of CCTV.
# The police cleared up 16% more crimes and offences in the 24 months after CCTV.
# There was no evidence that crimes were ‘displaced’ from the town centre to areas without CCTV – either the immediately surrounding area or the rest of the Police Sub-division.

Source

 

Tags:
Posted in CCTV. Tags: , . No Comments »

4.2 Million CCTV Cameras: Urban Myth or Fact?

The figure “4.2 million CCTV cameras in the UK” is often quoted, from everyone to the BBC to the House of Lords, but where does this figure come from?

The statistic comes from a paper published in 2002 by academics Michael McCahill and Clive Norris. The study was based on a survey of the number of CCTV cameras in two busy south London streets: Putney High Street and Upper Richmond Road.

The researchers sampled 211 “premises” - pubs, shops, banks and office blocks – and found that 41 per cent had CCTV systems, with an average of 4.1 cameras per system. They then assumed that this CCTV coverage was roughly the same across London, and multiplied by the number of VAT registered businesses in London. They then added the number of public camera based on transport, hospitals, schools, etc.  They then managed to produce the number of cameras for the London population, 500,000 for 7 million people. They then multiplied up to get the number of cameras in the country – 4.2 million. They have gone from two streets (two very busy streets) and extrapolated out across the entire country.

Tags:
Posted in CCTV. Tags: . No Comments »

UKs Traffic Cameras to be linked to ANPR system

According to leaked memos by the government is considering linking many, if not all, road pricing cameras, currently based in London, to the ANPR network.

This would give the police access to thousands of cameras, providing live information about millions of drivers. This project is made possible as the home secretary has given London Transport exception from the Data Protection Act

The continued expansion of ANPR fits in with the ACPO ANPR strategy

Full Article

Posted in ANPR. Tags: . No Comments »

Select Committee Report: Royal Academy of Engineering

In 2007 the House of Lords made a call for evidence, as part of their investigation into privacy  entitled “The Impact of Surveillance and Data Collection upon the Privacy of Citizens and their Relationship with the State several different bodies and individuals provided their expertise. One of these was the Royal Academy of Engineering.

The Royal Academy of Engineering conclusions, submitted in June 2007, where similar, though more muted, to those of others who submitted evidence (e.g GeneWatch)

The report made several statements that the balance of privacy and surveillance of the state is swinging in favor of the state. They found that CCTV can not be avoided, that “optional systems” like Oyster cards, which track peoples movements around London, were not optional, and that there was no clear line between beneficial surveillance and constitutionally improper surveillance.

Highlights from the report include:

  • The rise of camera surveillance probably has the greatest impact as individuals in public spaces cannot refuse consent for the recording of their image…..The increase in such surveillance means that the ‘big brother’ State becomes more than just a cliché. Authorities are watching citizens for increasing proportions of their daily lives and citizens have no power to reject such surveillance.
  • In the private sector, schemes like the Oyster travel card …..involve collection of data about individuals… people would miss out significantly on benefits and convenience if they refuse them or use them anonymously. These technologies …effectively collect data about peoples’ journeys …by stealth.
  • The existence and use of the National DNA Databases (NDNAD) raises significant questions regarding the rights of those on it. DNA profiles can be used to identify family relationships or to predict susceptibility to disease. ..An individual should have the right to withhold their DNA if there is no specific need for it in the investigation/prevention of crime.

This report, like the others submitted to the House of Lords Select Committee, showed that  UK government is on a direct path to have all the apparatus in place for a police state – even if that was not what they intend.

Royal Academy of Engineering Report

Laser Used Against CCTV

Lasers have been looked at defeating CCTV cameras with a vareity of different reports on the results. One of the main reported problems is that laser are too directional, and as such if not pointed directly at the CCTV lens do not work.

Hence people have used an arrary of IR LED lights to resolves the direction issues.

One post report the used of a laser used to defeat CCTV that was activated by a mobile phone, the idea being that laser is fastened into position prior to it being activated -  obvious that assumes that the laser and CCTV camera are both fixed and will not move.

Posted in CCTV. Tags: . No Comments »

Wider Deployment of ANPR 2004 to 2009

In 2003 Science Policy Unit produced a report for the “”Police Science and Technology Strategy” with a five year plan from 2004 to 2009.

Part of the plan was a significant increase in ANPR, the report states that: “Wider deployment of ANPR technology across the service to target known offenders.”

Full Report

Posted in ANPR. Tags: . No Comments »

More bodyscanners in the US

The US are to increase the number of “body scanners” at airports, which give the operator a “naked image” of person being examined from 40 to 120.

The devices can cause controversy as the allow the images of a person to be take that they probably would not normally want to be taken.

Bloomberg Article

The U.S. Transportation Security Administration will triple the number of devices at airports that can detect bombs under airline passengers’ clothing.

The purchase of 80 so-called Passenger Imager machines will bring the total in use next year to 120 at 21 airports, agency spokesman Christopher White said today.

The imagers are produced by L-3 Communications Holdings Inc., OSI Systems Inc.’s Rapiscan unit and American Science & Engineering Inc. The TSA hasn’t yet decided which vendors it will use or how much it will spend, White said in an interview.

IR used to defeat CCTV

We are repeatedly told the CCTV is here to protect us from the worst of the worlds offenders, including terrorists and international criminals. Despite the obvious flaw in the argument that suicide bombers are not bothered if they are filmed blowing themselves up (especialyl as they normally release videos to that effect shortly afterwards anway), there is the additional issue that if a person wants to hide their face from a standard CCTV camera it is incredibly easy.

A person can hide their face with a beard, material (mask/bandanna/etc), or they  can go slightly more high tech and use infrared lights.

A single point source of a IR Laser, if pointed directly at CCTV camera will flare the camera, however that involves a laser and the user to point and hold the laser directly at the camera. However, if the individual uses and array of IR LEDs then the effect is the same, as a single directed laser.

The idea is relatively simple, the user places IR LEDs in a “head torch, such as the one pictured inset. IR LEDS can be bought for just 79p and  LED head torches can be bought for just under £5 .  IR – Infrared - with a range of 750nm to 1mm has a range below the human eye, but can still be detected by CCTV cameras.

Below are the effects of using this type of  technology. There are flaw in this anti-CCTV devices. The LEDs need to be powerful enough, the and CCTV camera needs to not have an IR filter. It is is also possible, to enhance the blue green specturm after the incident to try and recover a better image.

Posted in CCTV. Tags: . 1 Comment »